The Indifferent World
OSR musings, part 1
The Death of the Protagonist
Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Mud
Welcome to our deep dive into the philosophy of Old School Renaissance (OSR) play. We’re going to dismantle the safety rails, tear up the script, and look at why playing a game where the world absolutely does not care about you is the most rewarding experience you can have with a set of polyhedral dice.
Today, we’re starting with the hardest pill to swallow: You are not the Chosen One.
Do you want more TTRPG ideas, thoughts, half-baked settings?
Don’t miss ZINE 2026.01, it’s free anyway!
The Lie of the “Chosen One”
If you’ve played modern RPGs or consumed any fantasy media in the last forty years, you know the drill. You have a mysterious birthmark. An old man in a tavern has a scroll with your name on it. The universe seems to bend around your character’s journey, ensuring that the challenges you face are perfectly tailored to your current power level.
It’s comfortable. It’s cinematic. And in the OSR, we throw it directly into the trash compactor.
In this style of play, you are not a protagonist written into a grand destiny. You are a grave robber with a rusty dagger and a staggering amount of student loan debt (or the feudal equivalent). The dragon in the mountain isn’t waiting for you to hit Level 15 so it can have a dramatic showdown; it’s there right now, and if you poke it with a stick at Level 1, it will eat you.
This sounds harsh, but here is the secret: A story written in advance is a railroad. A story that emerges from chaos is a memory.
When you survive in a world that owes you nothing—not balance, not fairness, and certainly not mercy—your survival actually means something. You didn’t win because the script said you would; you won because you were smart, lucky, and terrified.
The Referee is a Physics Engine, Not a Director
To make this work, the Referee has to undergo a radical personality shift.
In many games, the Referee acts like a movie director. They want “good pacing.” They want “narrative arcs.” If a fight is going too poorly, they might fudge a dice roll behind the screen to keep the hero alive, because it would be “anti-climactic” for the hero to die by tripping over a root and falling into a pit of slime.
In the OSR, the Referee must become a neutral arbiter. You are a physics engine with a pulse.
No Fudging: Roll in the open. If the dice say the goblin crits and decapitates the wizard, the wizard is decapitated. It’s tragic, yes, but it proves to the players that the danger is real.
Objective Reality: If a cliff is 100 feet tall, falling off it deals 10d6 damage. It doesn’t matter if falling off the cliff ruins the Referee’s plans for the evening. Gravity has no bias.
The Referee’s job isn’t to entertain the players; the Referee’s job is to simulate a world. The entertainment comes from the players trying to survive that simulation.
The “Quantum Ogre” Problem
There is a famous thought experiment in RPG theory called the “Quantum Ogre.”
Imagine the party comes to a fork in the road.
Path A leads to the Forest.
Path B leads to the Mountains.
The Referee has prepared a cool encounter with an Ogre.
If the players pick Path A, the Referee puts the Ogre in the Forest.
If the players pick Path B, the Referee puts the Ogre in the Mountains.
To the players, it looks like they made a choice. But in reality, their choice didn’t matter. They were fighting that Ogre no matter what. This is the illusion of choice, and it creates a safe, curated experience.
In an indifferent world, we reject the Quantum Ogre. If the Ogre is in the Forest, and the players choose the Mountains, they must never see the Ogre.
“But wait!” I hear you cry. “I spent two hours stating up that Ogre! I wrote him a monologue! If they miss him, I’ve wasted my time!”
Here is the hard truth: Player agency only exists if players can make the “wrong” choice.
If they can’t miss “content,” they aren’t exploring a world; they are riding a roller coaster. The roller coaster might have painted scenery on the left and right, but the track only goes one way. When players realize that they actually missed the Ogre—and that the Ogre is currently eating the villagers they didn’t save because they went to the mountains—the world suddenly feels massive, real, and alive.
So
Abandoning the role of “The Main Character” is scary. It means giving up the safety net. It means realizing that your character might die in a dirty hallway for no good reason other than bad luck.
But it opens the door to a different kind of heroism. Not the heroism of a demigod fulfilling a prophecy, but the heroism of a regular person staring into the uncaring maw of a dungeon and saying, “I’m going in anyway.”
The Mechanics of Unfairness
Or: Why “Balance” is a Five-Letter Word
We broke the bad news: your players aren’t the Chosen Ones, and the universe has no script for their success. We tore down the “Plot Armor.”
Now, we have to build something in its place. If we aren’t using “narrative balance” to run the game, what are we using?
We’re opening the hood of the OSR engine to look at the mechanics of unfairness. We are going to discuss why you should throw the concept of “Challenge Ratings” out the window, and why a random number generator is the fairest judge in the world.
Abolishing “Challenge Ratings” (CR)
In many modern RPGs, there is an implicit contract: The Referee will not put a monster in front of us that we cannot mathematically kill.
If a party of Level 1 adventurers walks into a cave, the game math suggests they should find goblins, rats, or maybe a very sleepy bandit. They should not find an Ancient Red Dragon. That wouldn’t be “balanced.”
In the OSR, we reject balance in favor of Logic.
If the party hikes up to the Peak of Death Mountain, they are going to find a Dragon. It doesn’t matter if they are Level 1 or Level 20. The Dragon lives there because it’s a mountain and he likes the view, not because the party’s average hit points have reached a specific threshold.
The Information Game
Now, this sounds like we’re just trying to kill the party. But we aren’t. We are simply changing the game from “Combat Sport” to “Information Warfare.”
Because encounters aren’t balanced, players can no longer kick down every door they see. They have to scout. They have to listen at doors. They have to ask locals about rumors.
If they charge blindly into a cave, they die. If they do their research and hear that “The Cave of Sorrow is home to a Shoggoth,” they can make an informed choice: run away.
Telegraphing Danger
Here is the Golden Rule of unfair play: Lethality requires Warning.
You cannot just say, “You open the door, a Medusa looks at you, save or die.” That’s not a game; that’s just bullying.
You must telegraph the danger.
Bad: “You see a Medusa.”
Good: “The hallway is filled with incredibly detailed stone statues of screaming adventurers. A distinct hissing sound comes from around the corner.”
If the players see the statues and still walk around the corner holding a mirror? That’s on them.
The Tyranny of the Random Table
If you want to convince your players that the world is indifferent to them, you need to stop deciding when bad things happen. You need to let the dice decide.
Enter the Reaction Roll and the Wandering Monster.
Dice as Destiny
In a narrative game, the Referee might think, “The party looks beat up. I’ll let them rest.”
In an OSR game, the Referee rolls a d6 every 10 minutes (or “dungeon turn”). On a 1, a monster appears.
The monster doesn’t care that the Cleric has no spell slots left. The monster doesn’t care that you’re trying to have a heartfelt roleplay moment about your backstory. The monster is hungry.
The Referee Shrugs
This mechanic is magical because it absolves you, the Referee, of guilt. When an Ogre wanders into the camp at 3:00 AM and smashes the Wizard, you don’t have to apologize. You can just point to the die sitting on the table and shrug.
“I didn’t want to kill you, Dave. But the Oracle of Plastic has spoken.”
This reinforces the theme: The world is alive, it is moving around you, and it is dangerous.
Environment as the Enemy
Finally, we need to remember that monsters are only half the problem. In a simulation-style game, the environment itself is trying to kill you.
Starvation and Torches
Tracking rations and torches is often seen as “boring bookkeeping.” In the OSR, it is the source of all tension.
Deep underground, light is life. If you have 3 torches left, and each lasts an hour, you have a 3-hour timer to get out of the dungeon before you are eaten by things that can see in the dark. That isn’t bookkeeping; that is a ticking time bomb.
Dungeon Ecology
Also, remember that dungeons aren’t hotels where monsters sit in their assigned rooms waiting for room service (the players) to arrive.
Think of the dungeon as an ecosystem. The Goblins on Level 1 are at war with the Orcs on Level 2. The Spiders in the corner eat anything that gets too close.
This friction creates opportunities for smart players. If the game is “unfair” and the Orcs are too strong to fight, maybe the players can bribe the Goblins to help them? Or maybe they can lure the Spiders into the Orc camp?
When the environment is alive, the players stop looking at their character sheet for answers and start looking at the world.
So
We have now established a world where the monsters are too strong, the random encounters are relentless, and the torches are slowly burning out. We have built a machine designed to crush the unprepared.
So… how do players actually survive this nightmare?
Triumph Without Scripts
Or: How a Bag of Flour is Stronger than a Fireball
We tore up your character’s “Chosen One” certificate and told you the world doesn’t care if you live or die. We filled that world with unfair monsters, uncaring dice, and resource management mechanics designed to stress you out.
By now, you might be asking: “Why would anyone play this? This sounds like a simulator for being miserable in a damp cave.”
But here is the payoff. When the safety rails are gone, and the encounters are unbalanced, something magical happens to the players. They stop pressing buttons on their character sheets and start using their brains.
The Shift from Character Skill to Player Skill
In many modern RPGs, your character sheet is a control panel. You encounter a problem, you look down, you find the skill that matches the problem (Perception, Persuasion, Athletics), and you press the button. You roll a die. The problem is solved (or not).
In the OSR, the character sheet is not a control panel. It is a receipt of things you own and a list of how likely you are to die if you get stabbed.
When the world is unfair, looking at your character sheet for a solution is usually fatal. If you try to fight the Ogre fairly using your “+1 To Hit,” the Ogre will smash you. The numbers are on his side, not yours.
So, you have to stop playing the character sheet and start playing the game. This is Player Skill.
Interrogating the Fiction
Player Skill means interacting with the world using logic, physics, and a healthy dose of paranoia.
Don’t ask to roll Perception. Instead, tell the Referee: “I’m pouring a bucket of water onto the flagstones to see if it drains through the cracks of a trapdoor.”
Don’t ask to roll Insight. Instead, ask the Referee: “Is the merchant sweating? Does he keep looking at the city guard while he talks to us?”
Don’t ask to roll Diplomacy. Instead, actually bribe the guard. Offer him 50 gold pieces and a nice bottle of wine.
Mechanics like “Insight” or “Investigation” are often just “Solve the Puzzle” buttons. When you remove them, players have to solve the puzzle themselves.
Earned Victories vs. Handouts
There is a specific psychological term for the feeling you get when you beat a challenge you know was capable of crushing you: Fiero. It’s that moment you throw your hands up and shout “YES!”
You cannot get Fiero from a balanced encounter. If you know the Referee curated the fight to ensure you had a 90% chance of winning, victory feels like completing a chore. It’s just paperwork.
But when you defeat the Ancient Dragon at Level 2—not because you had high stats, but because you lured it into a narrow tunnel and collapsed the ceiling on its head using a pickaxe and a delayed blast oil flask? That is a victory you will talk about for twenty years.
The Emergent Narrative
This is where the story comes from. The story isn’t “The heroes saved the kingdom because the prophecy said so.”
The story is: “Remember that time Torvald the Thief used a bag of flour to find the invisible stalker, threw a net over it, and we beat it to death with shovels?”
That is a messy, unheroic, and absolutely beautiful story. It wasn’t written by the Referee. It emerged from the collision of a problem (invisible monster) and Player Skill (flour).
Accepting Tragedy
Of course, sometimes the plan with the flour doesn’t work. Sometimes the ceiling doesn’t collapse on the dragon. Sometimes the dragon just breathes fire and everyone turns into ash.
In the OSR, we have to make peace with the TPK (Total Party Kill).
Death is not a failure state; it is a data point.
When a character dies, the player learns something. “Oh, giant spiders can jump.” “Oh, green slime dissolves plate mail.” The character is gone, but the player is smarter now.
There is a stark beauty in the “Anti-Climax.” Sometimes, the great warrior doesn’t die saving the princess. Sometimes, he trips a poison needle trap in a random hallway and dies foaming at the mouth. It’s tragic. It’s sudden. But it grounds the world. It proves that the danger is objective.
If the Referee saved that warrior because “it wasn’t a cool way to die,” the tension of the game evaporates. If you can only die when it’s dramatic, you are immortal until the season finale. And where is the fun in that?
The Sandbox Promise
We strip away the safety nets. We make the monsters too strong. We let the dice fall where they may.
Why?
To give you the ultimate respect a Referee can give a player: The Freedom to Fail.
Because if you have the freedom to fail—horribly, unfairly, and abruptly—then you also have the freedom to succeed. When you survive the dungeon, haul the gold back to town, and buy a castle, you know in your bones that you earned every single brick.
The world doesn’t care about you. And that is exactly why conquering it feels so good.
Now, go roll up a grave robber. You have a dungeon to explore.